Hmm, after checking the logs it looks like it isn't being called after the first time clicking the button.

Here is some more information about my project, I have a modal with an email input and a next button. When the button is clicked it creates a certain number of records depending on a list called selected resources. After the last record is created it updates the account with the email and calls that send email function if an email was inputted. I put in some toast messages for lazy debugging, every time I click the button both success toast messages are shown (first one being used to show that the right part of the if statement is being called every time and the second one being used to show that the email should have been sent). Since the second toast message was in the .then of the apex function I assumed it was being called.

Since that button updates the account and sends the email there should be 2 logs every time but after the first press only the update logs show up.

Here is the email input and button in the modal:

<lightning-input type="email" label="" onchange={handleEmailAdd} value={updateInput.fields.Email__c} placeholder="Type Here..."></lightning-input>
<button class="slds-button slds-button_brand" onclick={handleNext} title="Next">Next</button>

Here is the handleNext function:

handleNext() {
		this.isModalOpen = false;
		this.screenLoading = true;
		for (let i = 0; i < this.selectedResources.length; i++) {
			this.recordInput.fields.Name__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Name;
			this.recordInput.fields.Description__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Description;
			this.recordInput.fields.Phone__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Phone;
			this.recordInput.fields.Street_Address__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.BillingStreet;
			this.recordInput.fields.City__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.BillingCity;
			this.recordInput.fields.State__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.BillingState;
			this.recordInput.fields.Zip__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.BillingPostalCode;
			this.recordInput.fields.Food_Bank__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Food_Bank__c;
			this.recordInput.fields.Financial_Assistance__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Financial_Assistance__c;
			this.recordInput.fields.Shelter__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Shelter__c;
			this.recordInput.fields.Case_Management__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Case_Management__c;
			this.recordInput.fields.Serves_Meals__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Serves_Meals__c;
			this.recordInput.fields.Senior_Center__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Senior_Center__c;
			this.recordInput.fields.Housing_Assistance__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Housing_Assistance__c;
			this.recordInput.fields.Transportation__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Transportation__c;
			this.recordInput.fields.Social_Services_Assessment__c = this.recordId;
			this.recordInput.fields.Account__c = this.record[0].Account__r.Id;
			this.recordInput.fields.Resource_Account__c = this.selectedResources[i].value.Id;
			createRecord(this.recordInput)
			.then(() => {
				if (i == this.selectedResources.length - 1) {
					if (this.updateInput.fields.Email__c != '') {
						this.dispatchEvent(
							new ShowToastEvent({
								title: "Email",
								message: this.updateInput.fields.Email__c,
								variant: "success"
							}),
						);
						updateRecord(this.updateInput)
						.catch(error => {
							this.error = error;
							this.dispatchEvent(
								new ShowToastEvent({
									title: "Error",
									message: error.body.message,
									variant: "error"
								}),
							);
						});
						sendResources({email: this.updateInput.fields.Email__c, accountId: this.updateInput.fields.Id})
						.then(result => {
							if (result) {
								this.dispatchEvent(
									new ShowToastEvent({
										title: "Sent",
										message: result,
										variant: "success"
									}),
								);
							}
							else {
								this.dispatchEvent(
									new ShowToastEvent({
										title: "Not Sent",
										variant: "error"
									}),
								);
							}
						})
						.catch(error => {
							this.error = error;
							this.dispatchEvent(
								new ShowToastEvent({
									title: "Error",
									message: error.body.message,
									variant: "error"
								}),
							);
						});
					}
					this.selectedResources = [];
					this.noSelectedResources = true;
					this.screenLoading = false;
					this.vfpage = true;
				}
			})
			.catch(error => {
				this.dispatchEvent(
					new ShowToastEvent({
						title: "Error",
						message: error.body.message,
						variant: "error"
					}),
				);
			});
		}
	}